Concurrence with Overture 00-13.
On Striking G-6.0106b from the Book of Order
The Session of _______________ Church in _____________ respectfully
overtures the Presbytery of Southern New England to approve the
following action and instruct the Stated Clerk to send it to the 213th
General Assembly (2001)
The
Presbytery of Southern New England concurs with Overture 00-13. On
Striking G-6.0106b from the Book of Order, from the Presbytery of
Northern New England.
Rationale
Since the passage of G-6.0106b
it has become clear that Presbyterians are not of one mind about ordination
standards. The effect of this policy has been deep and painful division.
While its removal will not resolve all the underlying issues, it will create
an environment more open to study, reflection and prayerful consideration.
Consider the following
excerpts from Historic Principles, Conscience and Church Government,
adopted
by the 195th General Assembly, PC USA (1983), the first meeting of the
reunited UPC (USA) and the PC US:
Schism
is generally the result of an improper understanding or use of Presbyterian
polity. Lessons available to us from our history suggest the following
as contributing factors: ...a governing body assumes the simple majority
to be sufficient for taking action binding the conscience of a large minority....
Respect
for diversity is a central requirement for the peace and unity of the church....
Whether individual or corporate, the right of private judgment is a necessary
one. It includes the right to be wrong.... The church protects its own
minority point of view as if it were protecting its future, recognizing
that the dissenter may well represent the will of God....
There
are times when delay is a valuable way of avoiding premature decisions,
especially when the minority position is held by a fairly large number
of people.... Mutual forbearance is to be exercised by individuals within
the church toward one another. Forbearance is willingness to accept other
people in the church who do not share our own ideas. To exercise forbearance
is to accept diversity with gratitude for those who differ and willingness
to remain in conversation with people whose perspective may disturb us....
...all
church bodies must exercise care not claiming too much authority for themselves....
When an attempt is made to force consensus before the time is right, the
impatience of those who demand premature action may produce a lack of proper
attention to the convictions of a large minority. Such a lack is one which
produces ill will and potential for schism.... When a very close majority
vote is taken on an issue of importance, the result is often troubling.
While twenty-two more presbyteries voted for than
against G-6.0106b, a change of vote by 32 commissioners in 11 presbyteries
would have defeated it (based on analysis of announced votes). We are presently
struggling with the consequences of attempting too quickly to reach a decision. |